Ghost revenue: Is your marketing success haunting the boardroom instead of winning it?

Ghostly shapes including £ and $ signs haunt a spooky boardroom at night.

The source of growth in B2B organisations is sometimes murky and spectral, showing up in the numbers but vanishing in the story the CEO tells. That’s one of the findings of new research from Propolis and B2B Marketing, which says marketing needs to change the story, and how to be a commercial marketer

Four in five CEOs, 84% of them, still call marketing a support function rather than a growth driver. “Pretty staggering… pretty shocking result,” is how Richard O’Connor, CEO of B2B Marketing and Propolis, reacted when he first saw the number.

It’s one of the headline findings from new research Propolis, B2B Marketing’s membership and intelligence platform, carried out among 150 CEOs, each running organisations with at least £20 million in revenue and skewing toward much larger ones, £150 million and up. These CEOs put an average of 5.6% of turnover into marketing. On a recent episode of the Trust & Influence in B2B podcast, I spoke to O’Connor about what the research, titled the CEO Blind Spot and available in full to download now, uncovered, and what it will take to close the gap. Longtime listeners will know I’ve been a shareholder in B2B Marketing for over twenty years, separate from my work on this podcast.

The name matters. O’Connor was careful, on the podcast, to call it a blind spot rather than a failure. “It’s not a willful thing,” he said. “It’s a product of where we are, and some of the patterns and culture we find ourselves in,” shaped by years of post-pandemic economic pressure that have left CEOs with less time to look properly at what marketing does. A blind spot, as he put it, is solvable. A failure implies someone is to blame.

Ghost revenue: the growth nobody credits

The sharpest term to come out of the research is “ghost revenue,” O’Connor’s name for the growth marketing creates that nobody ends up crediting to marketing. “Sales, the contribution of sales, gets overweighted by the CEO,” he said. “They see the closed deal, the near-term impact of sales when it comes in, and I think they underestimate the role that marketing has played up to that point. It’s all of the work that’s contributed to the closed-won deal that just gets missed.”

It isn’t only a marketing problem, he argued. Sales is struggling with its own numbers too. “Look at the Salesforce annual report,” he pointed out. “They’ve been missing their targets regularly for the last three, four years.” The real story, O’Connor suggested, is less about marketing failing to prove its worth and more about a boardroom that scrutinises one function far more than the other.

What changes a CEO’s mind, in O’Connor’s experience, isn’t a better dashboard. It’s trust built over time. He described a CFO panel at a recent Propolis event where one finance leader explained why he backed his marketing team’s brand investment, something notoriously hard to put a number on. “I fundamentally trust the marketing function to demonstrate the bits that I need,” the CFO said. “I trust their judgement on the bits that I can’t measure. Having things that show me how the milestones ladder up to a commercial goal gives me the confidence even when I can’t see the immediate targets being met.”

The credibility crunch: why vocabulary isn’t the answer

A second finding, which O’Connor calls the credibility crunch, found that 88% of CEOs say marketers would be more credible if they spoke the language of business. It’s tempting to read that as a vocabulary problem, fixable by sprinkling EBITDA and P&L into the next board deck. O’Connor doesn’t buy it. “You don’t suddenly build boardroom trust by coming out and having a different vocabulary,” he said.

Real commercial credibility, he argued, looks more like account-based marketing done properly. “A good ABMer understands where growth is going to come from. They understand the growth goals, what’s going to come from existing customers through cross-sell and up-sell, and where new customers need to come from.” That forensic, account-by-account understanding of where the money comes from, not the jargon layered on top of it, is what earns trust. Robert Norum, Propolis’s resident expert on ABM and demand generation, makes the case that brand matters just as much in that model as anywhere else, O’Connor noted, not less.

Sometimes credibility is about more than figures entirely. O’Connor described one Propolis member, a CMO at a cloud computing business, who pushed back when her CEO asked her to cut her budget. “Fine,” she told him, “but I’m not going to be able to deliver your next year’s goals.” It worked, O’Connor said, because she’d already built the relationship and the track record that let her say it and be believed. As one contact of his, previously at Ogilvy and now running a consultancy called Navigate North, put it to him: sometimes CEOs can’t articulate the business strategy either. The credibility gap can run in both directions.

Excluded before they’re trusted

Two more figures sit close together in the research: 65% of CEOs don’t involve marketing in their full growth strategy process, and only 18% of marketers say they can consistently demonstrate business impact in the C-suite. Which comes first, the exclusion or the distrust?

For O’Connor, the exclusion comes first, and it’s a leadership problem more than a marketing one. “Marketers are kept outside of the strategic process,” he said. “They’re not involved in the forecasting process in the same way that sales are. They’re seen as the function that will deliver what’s already been decided.” Left out of the room where strategy gets made, marketing is left proving its value after the fact instead of shaping it from the start, which makes the 18% figure look less like underperformance and more like an inevitable result of where marketers are, or aren’t, sitting.

The AI value trap for commercial marketers

The most uncomfortable finding may be this one: 75% of CEOs have already cut marketing investment or headcount because of AI, and 80% believe they can keep cutting without hurting growth. O’Connor doesn’t dismiss the efficiency gains. “It’s a fantastic time to be working,” he said, but he’s blunt about where the real risk sits. “If AI is being used as air cover for cutting human expertise for the sake of cutting human expertise, that’s really short-sighted. Where is the actual justification for it?”

Used well, he argued, AI frees people up rather than replacing them. He pointed to Kate Hassler at Access Group, who has used it to redeploy marketers away from repetitive work and into higher value work, spending more time with customers, the kind of direct customer insight O’Connor believes is exactly what builds the commercial credibility marketing is short of elsewhere in the research. Cut the people doing that work to fund the AI rollout, and the blind spot gets wider, not smaller.

Own the agenda: how to be a commercial marketer

Asked what single change would move the 84% figure if Propolis repeated the research in three years, O’Connor didn’t hesitate: marketers owning the growth agenda rather than waiting to be handed one. “Don’t be subservient to sales,” he said. “Own the agenda, because you’re ultimately responsible for the number.”

The research backs him up on what’s at stake. 87% of CEOs say they want marketing that combines creativity, brand building and commercial impact, and when marketers earn commercial credibility, CEOs say they’re willing to back bolder creative and brand risk in return, in some cases as many as 90% of them. The ambition was never the problem. The visibility was.

What to do with this

None of this requires waiting for your CEO to change first.

  • Go back to the growth numbers you already have and connect them, account by account if you can, to the specific marketing activity behind them, the way a good ABM campaign would, so the next conversation about budget starts from evidence rather than defence.
  • Ask to be in the room where growth strategy and forecasting get decided, not just briefed on the outcome. If nobody’s invited you yet, make the case for why that conversation is incomplete without marketing in it.
  • Where AI has freed up time on your team, spend it with customers, not on more dashboards. That direct insight is one of the fastest ways to build the kind of credibility this research says CEOs are missing from marketing.
  • Resist the urge to prove yourself with fluency in business vocabulary alone. Credibility comes from demonstrating you understand where the business’s growth actually comes from, not from the words you use to describe it.
  • Treat brand and creative ambition as something you earn room for, not something you trade away for commercial credibility. The research suggests CEOs will back bigger creative bets once they trust the numbers behind them, not instead of them.

Download the CEO Blind Spot report here.

In this article

    Let's connect

    Whether you’re looking for a speaker, collaborator, or advisor, I’d love to help you bring fresh perspective to your B2B audience.

    Name(Required)

    Follow me on: