Show them the money, not the magic: How marketing can prove the value the board’s spreadsheet can’t see
Marketing should be one of the biggest drivers of company valuation, yet few boards truly recognise that, let alone give CMOs the latitude to realise that potential. In the first episode of Boardroom Blindspots, made with Gravity Global, Freemarket’s Nick Eades and Gravity Global‘s Chris Omotosho explain how to keep the workings backstage and put the evidence centre stage to demonstrate the value of marketing.
Ask a board what a company is worth and it will reach for the numbers it already trusts: revenue, margin, the assets it can count. Yet the part of a business that is hardest to put a figure on is often the part investors, shareholders and acquirers end up paying for. Reputation, relationships and the market’s belief in where a company is heading are built largely by marketing, and few of them appear in a board pack.
Boardroom Blindspots is a new three-part series on the Trust & Influence in B2B podcast, made in partnership with Gravity Global, exploring the gaps in how boards see where value really comes from. The first episode takes on the most literal of them: how a company is valued. I was joined by two people who see the problem from different sides. Nick Eades is Chief Strategy Officer at Freemarket, a PE-backed payments business, and has been a CMO five times and a CCO three times, mostly in private equity and venture-backed companies. Chris Omotosho is UK Managing Director and Chief Client Officer at Gravity Global, and has spent three decades on the agency side working with clients in aerospace, automotive, technology and financial services. Between them, they made a persuasive case that the blindspot is real, that marketing is partly responsible for it, and that it can be addressed.
Investors buy a machine, not a campaign
The clearest place to see that hidden value is the moment a business is put under scrutiny, whether by investors, shareholders or a potential acquirer. Nick has been through several exits and works on both sides of due diligence, and he has watched intangible value surface in due diligence in a surprisingly human form. Alongside the financial analysis, investors run structured voice-of-the-customer research, and at the end there are freeform sections where customers simply say, “I really like them because.” That sentence is reputation being priced into a valuation. And it doesn’t appear from nowhere. “If you’re running the events and building reputation and running the PR and comms,” Nick said, “you’re creating the envelope in which everything else works. If you didn’t do it, it wouldn’t happen.”
So what do investors and acquirers actually want to see? Nick’s answer was precise. “What you’re ultimately looking for is a repeatable, profitable, scalable customer acquisition and retention process. If you can evidence that, it’s very investable.” When a business plan says revenue will be far higher in three years, diligence asks how. “The answer is not luck. It’s a process.”
Chris put the same logic more simply: marketing influences customer behaviour, behaviour drives spend, spend drives growth, and growth drives valuation. “Really straight, easy line for me.” The two descriptions share something more important than their differences. Both treat marketing as a system that produces outcomes, not a series of activities that consume budget. Once you can prove the system works, as Nick put it, “I’m not just spending it, I’m investing it.”
Evidence is confidence to demonstrate the value of marketing
Nick was candid about the audience marketing is dealing with. CFOs and investors are numbers people, and “this is gonna sound tough. They don’t believe anything. They evidence everything.” His shorthand is that evidence is confidence. “CFOs get real comfortable when you can show a process that works when you’re not in the room.”
Chris pointed out that this has never been easier. He recalled a time when B2B success was measured by a CEO patting you on the back on a Monday after seeing your posters at the weekend. Now the data exists, and the risk is drowning the board in it. “It’s very easy to bombard people and bore people with data,” he said. “The shape, the cadence of your dashboard is so important.”
Occasionally, the value marketing creates is written into the deal itself. Chris recalled Lloyds TSB’s acquisition of Scottish Widows in 2000, a consumer-facing brand but an instructive case, in which £1.8 billion was attributed to infrastructure, operations and brand [link: source]. “It wasn’t claiming that the whole 1.8 billion was down to brand,” Chris said, “but there was enough recognition that the Scottish Widows brand carried this value with it that it needed to be a line item in the valuation.”
Show them the money, not the magic
Both guests were also willing to turn the spotlight on marketing itself. Asked whether the blindspot is the board failing to see marketing or marketing failing to make itself visible, Chris didn’t hesitate: “Sadly, I think it falls into the latter.” Click-through rates and views matter, he said, because they are how marketers learn and optimise. But the CFO “just wants to know what’s the output”, and marketers have spent too long reporting the inputs.
Nick reached for Jerry Maguire. The CFO says “show me the money” and doesn’t much care how you got there. Marketing’s budget comes off the cost line just above operating profit, so the maths has to work back from the bottom line. His rule: “Don’t confuse your leading indicators with your so what indicators.” Keep the workings for the team, and show the board the outcome in the context of where the business has agreed it is going. “Don’t show them the magic.”
Two practical ideas followed. Nick prefers to evidence results through RevOps, ideally aligned to finance rather than sales, because “it can be empirical. It’s finance to finance.” And Chris argued that marketers should stop reporting in a silo and buddy up with their peers, so the board sees the combined effect of the go-to-market effort rather than what marketing did with its budget.
Chris raised the obvious objection. Sales can point to cause and effect almost immediately, while marketing’s effects can take months, if not years, and many CMOs are judged on what they deliver this quarter. Nick’s answer was to do both at once, and he reached for a line usually attributed to Sun Tzu: “Tactics without strategy is just the noise before defeat.” Get stuck in tactics, he warned, and “you’ll tactic yourself into a circle of pointlessness and then you get fired.” The long-term destination has to be agreed and kept in view, so that each campaign can be shown to move the business towards it.
The ‘C’ is earned
The guests disagreed, usefully, on one point. Chris observed that the C in CMO is often a bit smaller than everyone else’s, and that until marketing has an equal footing, the problem won’t go away. He told the story of a marketing leader whose new CFO refused for weeks to confirm the budget. The reason, when it finally came out: “Whatever number I give you, you are going to spend it.”
Nick’s view is that the title is secondary. “The C, chief word, is earned. And you have to earn it. And you have to hold on to it.” His test came from a logistics CEO who had him rehearse a scenario: a fatality on site, TV crews waiting, the CEO delayed. What do you say to the cameras? “You have to say exactly what the CEO would say.” If you can do that, you’ve earned the chief.
Both positions hold, and they meet in the same place. Respect follows evidence, but the title shapes whether you get the chance to present it.
Shape the story your CFO tells
The most practical idea in the conversation came from Nick, and it changes what reporting is for. In many board meetings, he pointed out, it is the CFO who carries the commercial story of the business, including marketing’s part in it. When a board member asks how lead generation is going, “MQLs is not going to come out of his mouth.” The question is whether marketing has given the CFO “the ammunition, the words, the evidence” to tell that story their way.
That starts with asking how they want to receive it, ideally informally. Nick recalled taking journalists to Tokyo for a product launch at IBM and asking them how they were paid. By the thousand words, it turned out, so he gave them a thousand words, and the relationship was transformed. The same principle applies to finance. Find out what your CFO needs to defend the plan, give them exactly that, and “look after your CFO.” A CFO who can’t defend the numbers sends marketing into what Nick calls “the inspection cycle”. As Chris noted, that line of questioning usually starts from “what can I remove?”
The question that cuts through about the value of marketing
Chris offered one question every CFO should put to their marketing leader: “If I switched all of this off tomorrow, what’s the impact to my business?” A marketing leader who can answer that with evidence has addressed the blindspot. One who can’t has work to do.
The story of the value of marketing also has to land inside the business. Nick recalled British Airways’ 1997 tailfin rebrand. The lesson the agency took from it was that cabin crew, asked by passengers what had happened to the planes, answered that they didn’t know and didn’t like it either. Chris made the same point about talent: reputation attracts and keeps the best people as well as customers. Trust runs through the whole chain, from the board trusting the evidence, to the CFO trusting the CMO, to employees trusting the story enough to tell it themselves.
Valuation visibility: how to address this boardroom blindspot and demonstrate the value of marketing
None of this needs new metrics. It needs a clearer sense of who you are reporting to, and what they need to hear.
- Describe marketing to the board as a repeatable, profitable process for winning and keeping customers, and evidence it as one.
- Separate your leading indicators from your “so what” indicators, keep the former for the team, and take only the outcomes into the boardroom.
- Work with RevOps, ideally aligned to finance, so the numbers you present are ones finance already trusts.
- Report alongside sales and product on the combined effect of go-to-market, rather than defending marketing’s budget on its own.
- Ask your CFO how they want to hear from you, then give them the words and evidence to make marketing’s case in their own language.
- Prepare your answer to Chris’s question: what would happen to the business if marketing were switched off tomorrow?
Listen to the episode here:
Let's connect
Whether you’re looking for a speaker, collaborator, or advisor, I’d love to help you bring fresh perspective to your B2B audience.
Follow me on: